Blame it on escalating commercial real estate
costs. Or lengthening commutes. Or outsourcing. Or
globalization. Whatever the cause, it’s a fact:
Increasing numbers of employees are working in locations
remote from a home office. And by all accounts, it’s
a huge demographic: Out of about 140 million employed
Americans, at least 78 million can be categorized
as telecommuters, multisite workers, non-office workers,
mobile-office workers or frequent business travelers,
according to research firm Cahners in-Stat/MDR. More
impressive, International Data Corp. puts the total
of all mobile and remote U.S. workers requiring computing
resources away from a central office at 94 million.
It’s a trend that could also result in devastating
consequences if companies fail to maintain high motivational
and communication standards for this growing workforce
of remote workers, experts warn.
“By all means, today’s workforce is more
mobile and spread out than at any time in the past,” says
Rick Blabolil, president of incentive company Marketing
Innovators, and the incoming president of the Incentive
Marketing Association. “And now, with more and
more remote people, it’s really possible that
some in the home office can feel disconnected, too.” Blabolil
stresses the need for “internal marketing” as
no less important that a company’s outreach to
external markets.
Consider Tommy Lee Hayes-Brown, most recently the employee
engagement manager with Met Life Auto and Home, based
in Warwick, RI. Met Life’s vast presence and
multiple offices assures that thousands of its employees
work remotely, and the company markets to them aggressively.
“It’s management’s job when dealing
with rewards and recognition to not forget about satellite
employees,” says Hayes-Brown, himself based remotely
in Charlotte, NC, and who’s just assumed multicultural
marketing chores at the company. He suggests that these
outreaches can be epitomized by quite simple things:
If you throw an ice cream-and-cake party for the office,
for example, make sure to send offsite workers a coupon
or gift card for similar goodies.
“But it has to be a formalized process,” Hayes-Brown
warns. “You need a ritualized way of making sure
everyone is recognized, a checklist if necessary, to
assure that every employee has a touch point during
any given week or month.”
Met Life has institutionalized what Hayes-Brown calls
three tiers of recognition. The first is peer-to-peer
recognition, whereby employees can recognize any other
coworker for just about anything, with manager review
and approval.
The second is “recognition champions,” designated
managers at each remote locale make decisions on recognizing
top-performing employees, and the prize levels the
winners achieve.
The last tier is corporate recognition, whereby top
executives take recommendations from remote offices
to reward the best-of-the-best, in particular at a
formal recognition program once a year.
Met Life supports its recognition program with logoed
products like T-shirts and umbrellas, sporting such
company symbols as the cartoon dog Snoopy or the Met
Life blimp; the company even gives out expensive crystal
Snoopys for outstanding performance. And local managers
have the option of presenting employees with gift cards
to local shops or eateries.
Make It Official
A major organization that has institutionalized internal
marketing and rewards is Avis Budget Group, “based” in
Parsippany, NJ, with a handful of corporate employees,
but with a far-flung and pervasive network of small
offices — the company is comprised of virtually
all remote workers, most of them paid on an hourly
basis — constituting the world’s largest
car rental organization.
For example, at the simplest level of recognition,
managers can present workers with a “Note of
Thanks” and gift cards for jobs well done.
A “Living the Values” level recognizes
employees who have excelled at customer interaction
or took ownership of a team project, with such middle
tier levels allowing workers to go online to choose
a variety of gifts. The company’s “Destination
Excellence” recognizes the highest level of
commitment, perhaps to a project entailing months
of work and millions in savings. Here, recipients
may receive high-value gifts of up to $1,000 in value.
“And then there’s something that, when
we implemented it, we didn’t know how important
it would turn to be,” says Mark Servodidio,
executive vice president and chief human relations
officer with Avis Budget. “To reward someone
who’s been on the road a lot, we might get
him something for his desk, but then pick out something
for the spouse, perhaps with a note of thanks for
all the nights the worker spent away from home.
“It definitely gives the sense that we’re
all united,” he adds. “Because it’s
values-based, it becomes bigger than any one
location, even bigger than the brands themselves.” Servodidio
says the company uses logoed products like hats,
spongy cars or balls as fun communication pieces,
rather than as outright rewards.
Know Your Audience
“Great recognition programs have to be aligned,
which means they reward the right behaviors,” says
Chester Elton, senior vice president at recognition
company O.C. Tanner, who is co-author of The Carrot
Principle. “Secondly, they have to be impactful,
inclusive and meaningful; in other words, what does
the recipient value? Does he value time with his
family, sporting events, career enhancement courses?”
Remote workers are particularly prone to lame reward
ideas, Hayes-Brown says, no matter how well-intended
the motivation program is. A manager may be quite
aware that his Orthodox Jewish coworker down the
hall wouldn’t be thrilled with the gift of
a glazed ham, but it’s also his responsibility
to make sure gifts to remote workers don’t
fall equally flat.
“We encourage managers to actually survey their
employees, and ask them how they want to be rewarded,” says
Elton. “If you get the wrestling tickets mixed
up with the ones for the opera, you’re in trouble.” He
also recommends presenting awards that are personal
and cannot generally be purchased. For example, a
winner enjoying an online shopping experience or
gift card may also be presented with a bronze eagle,
gold medal or weighty corporate logo.
“And with remote workers, you can’t over-communicate,” Elton
observes. “Everyone must be brought into the
conversation. There is nothing worse than feeling
all by yourself.”
There are few cases where companies rely more on
remote workers than call centers. Not only are call
center agents themselves generally remote employees — the
biggest companies have offices everywhere, and augment
these with at-home agents — but the workers
themselves are remote from the very clients they
represent to the public. Call center workers, who
are generally lower paid employees with high turnover,
need formal motivational techniques perhaps more
than any other demographic of employee.
More Than Stroking
“Recognition is very important in this industry,” says
Dave Halter, director of sales and marketing for
The AnswerNet Network, based in Princeton, NJ, with
56 call centers in 24 states plus Canada. “People
want to know their work is appreciated, and that
they’ve accomplished something for another
company.” AnswerNet has 1,700 call center agents,
none of whom work in the home office.
Motivating call center folks entails much more than
mere stroking for its own sake; their assignments
can go far beyond typical customer service tasks,
into commercially and socially critical arenas. AnswerNet’s
call center agents augment client sales teams, provide
disaster information services (airplane crashes,
for example), and even staff suicide hotlines. The
company recently assembled its teams to field consumer
calls about the widely reported contaminated pet
food crisis, acting on behalf of the affected manufacturer.
Agents handled 265,000 calls in a day-and-a-half
from frantic pet owners.
“Our people can get quite stressed,” says
Halter, in a classic of understatement. “People
need pretty good motivation to handle this kind of
incredible load.”
He says that client letters of commendation are acclaimed
throughout the company, and every employee receives “turkey
money” direct from the president at Thanksgiving.
Last year, when 20 AnswerNet call centers received
Gold Club recognition for excellence from the Association
of TeleServices International, all honored agents
were feted at awards luncheons, and the ATSI plaques
were reproduced for every winning center.
AnswerNet even sees its clients getting in on the recognition
act. One that had outsourced part of its cold-calling
sales function to AnswerNet’s agents actually
recognized those very call center agents at its own
annual rewards program.
One significant, and increasingly popular, technique
used by AnswerNet to enhance communications to its
remote workers is computer instant messaging. In fact,
the use of IM is required of all AnswerNet call center
managers and agents. Not only does it provide a rapid
response method for client queries, but it’s
also a form of constant communications with headquarters,
something that “is really key to a remote environment,” Halter
says.
AnswerNet uses a variety of promotional products in
support of its worker communication and motivation
program, including logoed hats, pens and the like. “The
most popular thing we’ve ever given out is this
little soft brush that you can clean your computer
keyboard with,” says Halter. “That’s
logoed as well, and everyone who sees it wants one.
We’ve reordered it three times.”
“It’s actually a two-way responsibility,
in that both the home office and remote employees share
the need to stay connected,” says Jennifer Rosenzweig,
global employee practice leader with incentive house
Carlson Marketing Worldwide. From headquarters’ perspective,
she says, “that serves as the basis for recognizing
performance.”
An undeniable aid to formal recognition programs that
include remote and work-at-home employees is technology.
Congratulatory e-mails can be sent, Web portals filled
with gift choices can be accessed, points can accumulate
and workers can check their progress online
toward goals and rewards. Carlson is like several other
major incentive companies that build motivational programs
around gifts provided through Internet portals. Typically,
rewarded workers gain points for performance that they
can redeem through online catalogs of products. Alternately,
managers can award workers with ad hoc access for outstanding
performance on the spot.
Support from the Top
But any talk of products must always come back to
the underlying motivational program. Without a
program supported by company leadership, the awarding
of products doesn’t make sense.
“Sometimes it can be written, sometimes it’s
part of the corporate culture, but no matter how
big or small a company is, the program needs support
from leadership,” says Carole Erken, director
of human resources at Kaiser Permanente, based in
Los Angeles. The company is the largest not-for-profit
managed care organization in the United States, operating
in nine states with some 110,000 employees.
Erken has devised a “Manager’s Toolkit
for Rewarding, Recognizing & Engaging Our Employees” for
all Kaiser Permanente managers. It includes such
often-overlooked tools as a reward and recognition
tracking worksheet, whereby managers can actually
log in each case of recognition for each employee;
and a self-assessment tool, which tracks celebrations.
There’s also the critical worksheet on employees’ likes
and dislikes, and even how they preferr to be recognized — in
public or in private.
And no matter how formalized a program is, there’s
just to substitute for that personal touch.
“A couple of my employees worked on a three-month
project that took them away from their families supporting
a remote location in Bakersfield,” Erken notes. “I
wrote a letter to one family thanking them for all
the soccer games their mother had to miss, talked
about all the good she had done for the organization,
how proud we were of her, and enclosed an American
Express gift check asking them to do something as
a family to recognize their mother.
“I received e-mails from the children thanking
me, and the mother came in with tears in her eyes.
She said she had never felt that kind of recognition
from her family over a work event.”
Erken strongly encourages creativity in rewarding performance,
in particular in the remote call centers. These distant
offices have used such techniques as spinning wheels
and prize shows awarding $20 gift cards, for example,
before switching to another fun event.
Call center attendance has been a particular problem
for Kaiser Permanente, as it can be for all varieties
of remote locations with isolated workers. In response,
the company has devised recognition programs for teams
of employees competing with each other on attendance
records; the losing team has to cook breakfast for
the winners. Programs also have been devised to encourage
workplace safety. Employee bonus programs are often
tied to achieving these critical business issues, Erken
says.
“You also need to pay particular attention when
you’re dealing with different shifts,” she
notes. “Those people on the night shift are sometimes
forgotten.”
And the payoff? Experts are agreed that leadership
must know that the money it puts into motivational
programs pays off, through surveys, sales measurements,
customer satisfaction reports and the like.
For example, the call center company AnswerNet measures
in part its return on investment through a simple metric:
turnover. The call center industry, where skilled,
caring personnel is key, is plagued with an overall
turnover rate of 40% to 60% a year, imposing huge recruitment
and training costs on the industry, and the potential
for disastrous client dissatisfaction.
By contrast, AnswerNet experiences turnover of about
20%, “which I know is the lowest turnover ratio
of call center center agents in the industry,” Halter
says.
Chris Hosford is a freelance writer based in New York..
|